Warning: If you haven't seen or read Gone with the Wind and/or don't give a crap about it, then you'll feel the same way about this post.

I'm a huge fan of Gone With the Wind, both the book and the movie. I really like Scarlett too, the book only! The miniseries version was a complete monstrosity, but I digress. Now even though I love the original movie with all of my heart, I definitely feel that there is room for an amazing, rock-my-world remake. I think that they could include a lot of things from the book that got left out of the original that would make it all that more incredible, not to mention, bring this awesome classic to a whole new generation who may not be quite as sophisticated as myself.
So every now and then I'll google 'Gone With the Wind remake' in hopes of stumbling across some announcement that I may have missed that some major studio is going to do it, and do it right. BUT, I have yet to stumble across that announcement, what I do stumble across are lots of message boards where people talk about who should play whom if they were to make a new version, and those suggestions for the most part make me want to die. Some of the more idiotic ideas are:
Scarlett,
Lindsay Lohan, are they serious? Please tell me they're not serious!
Kiera Knightley and Reece Witherspoon, not as offensive as the Lindsay Lohan suggestion, but completely wrong!
Angelina Jolie, let me explain something people, scarlett starts out at 16 and is only 28 at the end, Angelina is already twice the age of beginning scarlett.
Emmy Rossum, I hate her too much, and she's just not stunning enough
Nicole Kidman, way too old!
Mischa Barton, I'm jumping off a cliff!
I do think Scarlett is the hardest to cast so I actually have no brilliant suggestions other than that I think it should probably be someone relatively unknown in their early twenties.
Rhett
Matthew McConaughey, alright alright alright...NO!
Orlando Bloom, Nope, I loves me some Orlando Bloom, but he isn't anywhere near old enough or rugged-manly enough.
Ben Affleck, not quite.
Leonardo Dicaprio, ugh.

I'm pretty convinced that it should be Gerard Butler, if he could get the accent right, and I have faith that he could. I'd also be willing to consider Hugh Jackman, though watching The Fountain has given me some bad feelings towards him (only because it was so boring and nonsensical that it made me want to kill myself). And George Clooney, though it's hard for me to think of him as anything beside a television ER doctor even though he's legit as could be these days.
As far as Ashley goes I haven't really seen many stupid suggestions and I'm decided on Jude Law, good looking, but ultimately pretty useless and kind of more trouble than he's worth.
Melanie is also kind of hard because she's supposed to be pretty homely and aside from Julia Stiles who I wouldn't want to see playing her, you don't see many homely women in Hollywood. I'm open to Alexis Bledel, who I think is completely gorgeous, but if they moused her out then, maybe. Also maybe Ginnifer Goodwin, although anything I've ever seen her in she's pretty funny, so she'd have to play it just right.
*EDIT* I've recently become determined that Natalie Portman (beauty played way down of course) just might be THE perfect Melanie.
Anyway, I clearly have no life to have spent so much time and effort thinking about this and I'm kind of embarrassed about that but that's who I am. Do you guys have any casting suggestions?